ADVERTISEMENT

Seems like many of us are getting hit up to review products on our blogs in exchange for free stuff.

So, if you received the free stuff stuff, and it did not meet up to expectations, would you still review it?

Would you give it a poor review?

Views: 33

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I agree with this. If I can't post positive I contact the company so they know and then give them the chance to say yay or nay on if they want me to post it or write the review and send to them so they can have my opinion on what I think needs work on with a product. I have only had one item that I had a few minor things I thought should be changed and the company told me to go ahead and post it
I guess it helps to be honest with your readers and let them know what you do not like about a product and what you do like. It could also help the manufacturer- if they even read it. But, if the product has no positive attributes, I would not post anything.

thanks all!
I agree with Beth. If there is something that you really think is a bad idea/product/etc then wouldn't you want to let your readers know? There are ways to write a negative opinion of something without completely bashing a product or company.
This is a really interesting question to me since I haven't started reviewing products yet? What are the ramifications of giving honest but "poor" reviews? Will sponsors stop coming? Am I naive in believing that sponsors want to know what the public thinks of the product and how they can improve it or are they just using us for "almost free" advertisement?

I like what Toni said about contacting the company first to give them your feedback before you post. That's a great idea, thanks Toni! http://www.mombloggersclub.com/xn/detail/988554:Comment:246561

Thoughts?
There was actually an article related to this very topic in a recent Sunday edition of The Indianapolis Star. You can read it HERE.

Personally, I have not offered any freebies on my blog as yet. However, if and/or when I do, you can bet I will be honest - whether it is a good review or a bad review - because really, I don't feel I am giving an honest-to-goodness review of something if I sugar-coat my true feelings of the product and its performance.
I would absolutely post the poor review but would do it in a respectful, non- bashing manner. I agree with everyone who said how could you possibly trust a reviewer if every review was a glowing one?? If you want to develop a trusted, clear voice then you have to provide balance. Otherwise you just become another face in the crowd doling out meaningless reviews just to get a few free things. What's the point of that? I don't get it.
I would. The point of a review is to actually REVIEW the product, not blow smoke up the company's ass. Plus, I want my readers to feel they can trust me and if I'm just kissing up to everyone who sends me something then I'm not reliable or trust-worthy.

Having said all of that, I would try to make my negative review as constructive and kind as possible. I wouldn't just call something a piece of crap. :)
I have yet to see a negative review on a fellow Mom Bloggers site, have you? Maybe it is just the blogs I visit. I have a feature clld Product Junkie Approved so the bad ones will never make it since it is only products I really like and approve. I have had several products that I didn't like and I told the companies.
I absolutely would - this speaks to the whole idea of bloggers' integrity. If you didn't like the product and say you do, you're lying.

However, I completely agree with the other comments which suggest contacting the PR department ahead of time, providing only constructive criticism instead of a simply nasty review and noting any of your particular quirks which caused you to give the product a good review.

Great question!!
Yup...and I have!!
I've had only good reviews so far. I'd contact the company before you post it.

Reply to Discussion

RSS

FOLLOW US

OUR BLOG

The Story Behind The New Must-Have Nursery Item Of The Season + Giveaway

Babies are irresistible when they are sleeping, as every mom knows. This is what inspired Rookie Humans' founder and momma of two, Gabriela Anggono, to launch a whimsical line of crib sheets designed to create beautiful backdrops for…

OUR DAILY PINS

Latest Activity

Anna Rathkopf replied to Fiza Khan's discussion 'Post Your Link Here and Get Followers'
5 minutes ago
Mumsy and Bub replied to Mom Bloggers Club's discussion 'What's New With You?'
33 minutes ago
Profile IconGinny Bowen Olson, jenn powell, Paige White and 2 more joined Mom Bloggers Club
5 hours ago
Profile IconMom Bloggers Club via Facebook
Thumbnail

WIN these beautiful crib sheets by Rookie Humans. Adorable. 5 winners. http://mombloggersclub.com/page/the-story-behind-the-new-must-have-nursery-item-of-the-season-giv

See More
Facebook6 hours ago · Reply
Profile IconMom Bloggers Club via Facebook
Thumbnail

Make your child smile and think of you everyday with creative, fun, personalized daily lunch notes. Monthly subscriptions available. http://www.pollyslunchnotes.com #ad…

See More
Facebook6 hours ago · Reply
Adrienne Brown replied to Adriel from the Mommyhood Memos's discussion 'introduce yourself and leave your baby blog link here!' in the group Oh Baby! {pregnancy & baby blogs}
6 hours ago
Adrienne Brown joined Adriel from the Mommyhood Memos's group
6 hours ago
Brynn McDowell posted photos
6 hours ago

Advertisement

© 2017   Created by Mom Bloggers Club.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service